In brief
NetSuite was a San Mateo company, incorporated in September 1998 and headed by co-founder Evan Goldberg, a former Oracle developer, with Larry Ellison's money. It sold small businesses accounting, then an online store and CRM, as a single subscription through the browser. By its 2007 IPO it had 5,400 active customers and an accumulated deficit of $241.6 million; it closed every year from 2002 to 2015 with an accounting loss, and in 2016 it went to Oracle at $109 a share, about $9.3 billion, while its largest owner was that same Ellison, the buyer's chairman of the board and chief technology officer. It is a story about how long a company can live at a loss when its owner has an almost bottomless wallet, and about how such a deal had to be answered for in court for almost eight years.
How it started (the founders)
From August 1987 to November 1995 Goldberg worked in development at Oracle and rose to vice president of development in the New Media division; he then founded mBed Software, which made multimedia tools for websites, and was its CEO until September 1998. So by the time of the founding he knew Oracle from the inside, knew the web, and knew Ellison personally estimate: there are no direct documents about the acquaintance, but the link between a former employee and a former employer is visible from his biography.
The first version of the founding myth goes like this: a short phone call between Goldberg and Ellison, in which Goldberg proposes a tool for working with sales and Ellison insists that the back office, accounting and ERP, has to come first rumor: there is one source, and it is secondary. What the documents show is something else: the company was incorporated in California in September 1998, the first application, NetLedger, with a focus on accounting, came out in 1999, the online store in 2000, CRM and sales force automation in 2001, and the suite was released under the NetSuite name in 2002. The order of accounting first and sales second matches what gets retold, and differs from Salesforce, which started with salespeople.
The money came mainly from Ellison through Tako Ventures. The figure of $124–125 million is cited only in retellings rumor; the S-1 gives no amount, only that by 2005 Tako was the "majority stockholder" and had given the company a line of credit. Ellison was chairman of the board until 2003; in January 2003 the management was restructured: Nelson became CEO, and Goldberg CTO and chairman.
Year-by-year timeline
- 1987–1995: Goldberg works in development at Oracle, then as VP of Development in the New Media Division fact
- 1995–1998: Goldberg founds and runs mBed Software fact
- 1998: the company is incorporated in California in September; Goldberg is founder and CEO fact
- 1999: the first application, NetLedger (accounting), comes out fact
- 2000–2001: an online store (2000) and CRM and sales force automation (2001) are added fact
- 2002: revenue of $3.1 million against a cost of revenue of $5.3 million, that is, a gross loss; a net loss of $22.1 million; NetSuite becomes the brand; Nelson arrives in July fact
- 2003: revenue of $8.3 million, a loss of $22.7 million; in January Nelson becomes CEO, Goldberg CTO and chairman; the company claims 6,000 customers estimate
- 2004: revenue of $17.7 million, a loss of $28.6 million, sales and marketing $27.0 million fact
- 2005: revenue of $36.4 million, a loss of $57.7 million (the largest until 2013), development spending grew from $8.0 million to $24.8 million; a $10 million credit line from Tako and the first Oracle license fact
- 2006: revenue of $67.2 million, a loss of $35.7 million; the Tako line is increased to $20 million fact
- 2007: in October the board renounces the corporate opportunity doctrine with respect to Ellison; Ellison transfers his shares (≈61%) to a separate LLC; on 2007-12-19 the IPO is priced at $26; trading on the NYSE (ticker N) from 2007-12-20 fact
- 2007–2010: losses of $23.9 → $15.9 → $23.3 → $27.5 million on revenue of $108.5 → $152.5 → $166.5 → $193.1 million; Ellison's stake is 53.2% (2008), 51.6% (2009), 49.3% (2010) fact
- 2011–2015: the loss grows: $32.0 → $35.2 → $70.4 → $100.0 → $124.7 million; 2015 revenue is $741.1 million fact
- 2016: on 2016-07-28 Oracle announces the acquisition at $109 a share, ≈$9.3 billion; it closes on 2016-11-07 fact
- 2017–2025: a lawsuit by Oracle shareholders (case 2017-0337): a ruling for Ellison in May 2023, affirmed by the Delaware Supreme Court on 2025-01-21
Lesser-known but significant facts
- Ellison was not only the owner but also a lender secured by all the assets. From 2005 there was a $10 million Tako Ventures line of credit, from 2006 a $20 million one, at prime + 1% and secured by "substantially all of the Company's assets"; the $8.0 million balance as of 2007-09-30 was to be repaid with IPO proceeds.
- In 2002 the company sold for less than it cost to serve. Revenue of $3.1 million, cost of revenue of $5.3 million, a gross loss of $2.1 million, and $9.9 million went to sales and marketing. This was not a slow start but a deliberate payment for growth.
- Ellison gave up the vote of his shares before the IPO. He transferred 31,964,898 shares to an LLC whose agreement neutralizes their vote while he works at Oracle, with the stated aim of avoiding and mitigating possible conflicts of interest. Nine years later it was this very structure that became one of the arguments of the defense (the court did not find him to be a controlling stockholder) estimate. A caveat: the LLC agreement neutralizes the vote only in certain situations, and Ellison kept the right to vote on a merger for cash or securities.
- NetSuite bought Oracle licenses from Oracle. From 2005 there were three agreements for the database and the application server: $2.5 million, $0.9 million, and $4.2 million plus $1.4 million for support; the prospectus itself calls Oracle a potential competitor. From 2005 NetSuite's cloud ran on the licensed database of its future buyer.
- The IPO went by auction and priced above the assumed price. The assumed price in the S-1/A was $20.50, the midpoint of the $19–22 range; the result was $26; the range was raised twice during marketing estimate.
Legend vs. the record
- Legend: NetSuite is an Oracle subsidiary. It is often called that because it has been one since 2016, and because it was founded by a former Oracle employee with the money of Oracle's head. The record: from 1998 to 2016 NetSuite was a separate company, public from its 2007 IPO (NYSE: N); it was owned personally by Ellison through Tako and then the LLC (≈61% in 2007, 40.1% at the end of 2015), while Oracle was its license supplier and a potential competitor. Verdict: false for 1998–2016, true from 2016-11-07; the mistake is taking Ellison's personal capital for Oracle's capital.
- Legend: Oracle overpaid for NetSuite because of Ellison. The record: a premium of 19% to Wednesday's close of $91.57, and about 30% to Tuesday's close by other calculations estimate; the price was agreed by a special committee of Oracle's board made up of independent directors and by a committee of NetSuite's board; and the deal required the approval of a majority of the shares not owned by insiders and Ellison's people, which reached 53.2% against the required 50%. In court Ellison was not found to be a controlling stockholder, and Oracle and NetSuite were not found to be significant competitors; the case was decided in his favor in 2023 and affirmed in 2025. Verdict: the court says no, but Ellison personally received on the order of $3.5 billion estimate; the conflict of interest was real, the overpayment was not proven.
- Legend: NetSuite is the very first cloud company. That is how it is put in Oracle's press release, which in the same place says that in 1998 NetSuite founded the world's first company created to sell business software over the internet. The record: incorporation in 1998, the first application in 1999, the same year Salesforce was founded; Salesforce's 2004 prospectus names NetSuite as one of its competitors in the on-demand model. Verdict: a slogan, not a fact; priority in selling accounting by subscription is open to dispute, and the claim to be the first among the survivors needs separate verification unverified.
- Legend: Ellison came up with and created NetSuite. The record: in the S-1 Goldberg is a co-founder ("co-founded"), in Oracle's press release he is the Founder; Ellison was the financier and, until 2003, the chairman. The accounting-first idea is attributed to Ellison only by retellings. Verdict: the money and the board were Ellison's, the product and the management were Goldberg's and Nelson's; there is no primary source on Ellison's share in the idea rumor.
The first growth lever
Not a channel but a source of money. Revenue grew 1.8–2.7 times a year: $3.1 million (2002), $8.3 million (2003), $17.7 million (2004), $36.4 million (2005), $67.2 million (2006). Sales and marketing meanwhile cost $9.9 million, $15.4 million, $27.0 million, $39.2 million, and $43.9 million, more than revenue in 2002–2005 (about 152% in 2004 and about 108% in 2005). The owner covered the difference, with equity and with a $10–20 million loan secured by all the assets. The second part of the lever was the suite: the customer bought accounting, the store, and CRM together; according to the company itself, by 2003 it had more than 6,000 customers estimate. The subscription pricing scheme does not appear in the primary sources unverified.
The paired story
- Common thread. Both companies sold business software by subscription through the browser: NetSuite was incorporated in 1998, Salesforce in 1999; both had their headquarters in California (until 2007 NetSuite was also incorporated there, while Salesforce was incorporated in Delaware), and both had roots in Oracle: Goldberg and Nelson worked there, and Benioff left it as a senior vice president.
- Ellison. At NetSuite he was the controlling owner, with ≈61% in 2007 and 40.1% in 2015 according to the documents, and a lender as well. At Salesforce, according to a 2000 Techdirt blog post and later retellings, he was an early investor with $2 million, with no entry in the prospectus estimate. Ellison's sum in NetSuite ($124–125 million) is cited only by retellings rumor.
- Contrast in outcome. Salesforce went public in 2004 and stayed independent; NetSuite had its IPO in 2007 and was bought by Oracle in 2016, with the deal closed on 2016-11-07 per the 8-K.
- Contrast in market. Salesforce started with salespeople, NetSuite with accounting; in the 2000s they converged on small and midsize businesses.
- Contrast in money. Salesforce grew on venture rounds (about $64 million before the IPO), NetSuite on the money of a single owner and on a loss that by 2007 had built up to an accumulated deficit of $241.6 million.
Parallels today (projects from the catalog)
- Nautis (
nautis) is a digital co-pilot for a founder: one workspace instead of a dozen programs (CRM, documents, finance). It is the same bet NetSuite made in 2007, when a spread of its prospectus presented it as a unified system for running a business. The difference of eras: then the suite came with a license for the Oracle database, today it comes with an AI that holds the context. view this project's dossier → - BillHog (
billhog) is a page, built on top of Stripe, where the customer enters their own details for an invoice. This is the very back office that, according to the retelling, Ellison told the founders to start with: accounting and invoices, the boring but paying part of a business. view this project's dossier → - Onigiri (
onigiri) offers simple invoices for a freelancer instead of bloated all-in-one CRMs. It is the opposite of the NetSuite suite: the same small-business customers, but instead of one big subscription, one small function. view this project's dossier →
What a builder can take from this in 2026
- A subscription needs a wallet, not just an idea. With revenue of $3.1 million in 2002, spending on sales and marketing was three times larger; the company survived because its owner was willing to lend. Today, first count the months of runway at a negative margin, not just the growth.
- A loss during growth is not a death sentence if cash flow is growing too. In 2015 the loss was $124.7 million with operating cash flow of $100.4 million, according to the company's press release estimate. Track GAAP and cash separately, as NetSuite did.
- Put the conflict of interest on paper before the deal. The transfer of the shares to the LLC and the renunciation of the corporate opportunity doctrine in 2007, the independent committee and the majority of unaffiliated shareholders in 2016: these papers became part of the defense, and the case was decided in Ellison's favor in 2023 and 2025 estimate. If you have a large strategic shareholder, formalize this on the day they come in, not on the day of the sale.
- Dependence on the buyer's database is both a risk and an asset. Three Oracle licenses made NetSuite cheaper and at the same time more dependent; the platform you stand on is better formalized in a contract with a reciprocal clause.
- Do not call yourself the first without a document. The slogan about the very first cloud company is easy to check: incorporation in 1998, product in 1999. Today the same applies to any claim to be the first AI something: a verifiable date matters more.
Discrepancies and what we could not verify
- Ellison's starting sum ($124–125 million): retellings only; the S-1 does not name an amount rumor.
- The story of the Goldberg–Ellison call and the accounting-first advice: retellings; Goldberg's interview could not be accessed rumor.
- The fall in Ellison's stake from ≈61% (2007) to 40.1% (2015): the number of his shares in the LLC barely changed (31,964,898 and 31,964,891), while the number of shares outstanding grew (≈52 → ≈82 million), so the cause is dilution.
- $9.3 billion versus ≈$9.4 billion: different ways of counting.
- Customers: 6,000 customers (2003, the company's own words) and 5,400 active customers (2007) are different definitions and cannot be compared estimate.
- The subscription pricing scheme could not be found unverified; the losses for 2008–2010 are confirmed by the 10-K.
- The size of Oracle's premium: 19% to Wednesday's close and about 30% to Tuesday's close; it depends on the base of comparison estimate.
- The 2018 and 2020 stages of the case: from legal summaries only estimate.
- Launch year: 1998 is the incorporation and the first application came out in 1999; here 1998 is counted as the launch year unverified.
Sources (primary first)
- NetSuite S-1/A, 2007-12-19
- Oracle, press release on the acquisition of NetSuite, 2016-07-28 (8-K ex. 99.2)
- NetSuite, 8-K on the closing of the deal, 2016-11
- NetSuite, 10-K for 2015
- NetSuite, press release on 2015 results, 2016-01-28
- NetSuite, press release on the IPO price, 2007-12-19
- InternetNews on the NetLedger management changes, 2003-03-28
- Irish Times on Ellison's stake, 2016
- PYMNTS on the deal, 2016-07-28
- Cornerstone Research on the Oracle case
- Sidley on the Delaware Supreme Court ruling, 2025
- Renaissance Capital on the IPO price